Guide · Phishing & scams

A real Google alert says you owe $399? Don't call

An email lands that looks exactly like a Google security alert, and it is: it really was sent by Google. Inside, where the app name should be, sits a $399 McAfee invoice and a phone number to call if the charge isn’t yours. It’s a callback scam. The alert is about the scammer’s own Google account, not yours, and the only “fix” it leaves you is the phone number.

In under a minute:

  • Don’t call a phone number from an email about a charge. Nothing in your account is wrong.
  • Read the account line. If the alert names an account that isn’t yours, it isn’t about you.
  • Check yourself. Look at your card or bank statement directly, and review your Google account’s security activity by signing in on your own.

Give everyone the same rule for “call us about this charge” emails. The Small Business Security Essentials Toolkit ($79) includes Desk card 1 (scam red flags), Decision tree 4 for suspicious emails and messages, and a handoff sheet for the real bank and vendor numbers so no one has to call the number in the email.

What happened

On October 6, 2026, the University of Michigan’s IT security team published a phishing alert about a message titled “App password created to sign in to your account.” The scammer had set a fake $399 McAfee invoice and a support phone number as the label of an app password on their own Google account. That made Google generate a genuine, signed security alert containing the scammer’s text. Google sent it to the scammer’s recovery address, which routed it through a compromised high school’s Microsoft 365 account that forwarded it on. Because it carried valid Google and Microsoft signatures, it passed the university’s email gateway checks. The university said no university account or system was compromised.

A November 2 write-up reports copies of the message are still circulating.

The trap, step by step

  1. The scammer creates an app password on their own Google account and types the fake invoice and phone number into its name.
  2. Google sends its normal alert to that account. The text inside is the scammer’s.
  3. They forward that real alert to you. The sender is genuine Google, so filters often trust it.
  4. You click “Check activity” and land on your own clean dashboard. The university called this an intentional dead end that leaves calling the number as the only apparent way to resolve the problem.
  5. The call is where the money is lost.

The tells

TellWhat it looks like
An invoice or phone number inside a security alertA security alert has no reason to bill you or ask you to call
The alert is about another accountThe account email in the message isn’t yours
A charge for software you never bought“McAfee subscription, $399.00”
Nothing wrong when you checkYour own Google account shows no new app password

What to do

  1. Don’t call the number or click anything in the message.
  2. Check the charge where it would really appear: your card or bank statement, opened on your own.
  3. Remember Google’s own rule: Google says it will never call you about your account’s security, and any unsolicited message claiming your account was hacked is a scam (Google Help).
  4. Report it as phishing in your email app, then delete it.
  5. Already called? If you let someone connect to your computer or paid anything, disconnect the computer from the internet, call your bank right away, and change your passwords from a different device. Our fake virus pop-up guide covers the same remote-access trap.

If you run a team

Bottom line

A genuine sender doesn’t make the message genuine. If an alert wants you to call a phone number about a charge you don’t recognize, don’t call. Check the charge yourself.

Prefer video? Watch the under-a-minute version on YouTube: A Real Google Alert Says You Owe $399? Don't Call.

Free next step: Get the Small Business Cybersecurity Checklist — download it now, or sign up there to get it by email and hear about new guides.